Posts: 4,160
Threads: 360
Likes Received: 2,306 in 1,515 posts
Likes Given: 1,316
Joined: Jun 2018
03-09-2022, 08:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-09-2022, 08:41 AM by LevelUP.)
Humanities degrees and STEM degrees deserve equal respect
http://www.reflector-online.com/opinion/...edd32.html
Should we respect these degrees?
What are the downsides to earning a Humanities degree?
Degrees: BA Computer Science, BS Business Administration with a concentration in CIS, AS Natural Science & Math, TESU. 4.0 GPA 2022.
Course Experience: CLEP, Instantcert, Sophia.org, Study.com, Straighterline.com, Onlinedegree.org, Saylor.org, Csmlearn.com, and TEL Learning.
Certifications: W3Schools PHP, Google IT Support, Google Digital Marketing, Google Project Management
![[-]](https://www.degreeforum.net/mybb/images/collapse.png)
•
Posts: 2,859
Threads: 143
Likes Received: 1,700 in 1,000 posts
Likes Given: 825
Joined: Jun 2017
Humanities degrees should be equally respectable if they want to be equally respected. Don't get me wrong, some are, but many are chosen because they're "easier" than STEM degrees. Of course, some STEM degrees are becoming somewhat easier now too since a lot of universities were finding that more applied technology focused programs don't need as many high attrition, "filter" courses in order to have good outcomes.
I think that ultimately, it should come down to the individual. Are they competent in their field? If so, they deserve respect regardless of their chosen degree.
WGU BSIT Complete January 2022
(77CU transferred in)(44/44CU )
RA(non WGU)(57cr)
JST/TESU Eval of NAVY Training(85/99cr)
The Institutes, TEEX, NFA(9cr): Ethics, Cyber 101/201/301, Safety
Sophia(60cr): 23 classes
Study.com(31cr): Eng105, Fin102, His108, LibSci101, Math104, Stat101, CS107, CS303, BUS107
CLEP(9cr): Intro Sociology 63 Intro Psych 61 US GOV 71
OD(12cr): Robotics, Cyber, Programming, Microecon
CSM(3cr)
Various IT/Cybersecurity Certifications from: CompTIA, Google, Microsoft, AWS, GIAC, LPI, IBM
CS Fund. MicroBachelor(3cr)
Posts: 1,826
Threads: 48
Likes Received: 456 in 303 posts
Likes Given: 289
Joined: Jun 2012
"Humanities degrees and STEM degrees deserve equal respect"
no
in fact, I think student loans should only go to STEM degrees
that should have the effect of actually lowering the cost of non-STEM degrees
and actually weeding out the useless degrees
•
Posts: 11,051
Threads: 153
Likes Received: 5,985 in 3,988 posts
Likes Given: 4,164
Joined: Mar 2018
Humanities degrees can be just as useful as STEM degrees. "Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it." 
In progress:
TESU - BA Computer Science; BSBA CIS; ASNSM Math & CS; ASBA
Completed:
Pierpont - AAS BOG
Sophia (so many), The Institutes (old), Study.com (5 courses)
ASU: Human Origins, Astronomy, Intro Health & Wellness, Western Civilization, Computer Appls & Info Technology, Intro Programming
Strayer: CIS175, CIS111, WRK100, MAT210
Posts: 1,097
Threads: 41
Likes Received: 353 in 237 posts
Likes Given: 0
Joined: Jun 2020
No lolo bluebooger"Humanities degrees and STEM degrees deserve equal respect"
no
in fact, I think student loans should only go to STEM degrees
that should have the effect of actually lowering the cost of non-STEM degrees
and actually weeding out the useless degrees
That sounds like a plan. NOT. That’s absurd.
Think we have worker shortages now. Deny student loans to future teachers , psychologists, social workers , nurses, ect and then see where we’re at.
Posts: 11,051
Threads: 153
Likes Received: 5,985 in 3,988 posts
Likes Given: 4,164
Joined: Mar 2018
I'm not sure that nursing could be considered a humanities degree. But the point still stands that there are some very important humanities degrees.
In progress:
TESU - BA Computer Science; BSBA CIS; ASNSM Math & CS; ASBA
Completed:
Pierpont - AAS BOG
Sophia (so many), The Institutes (old), Study.com (5 courses)
ASU: Human Origins, Astronomy, Intro Health & Wellness, Western Civilization, Computer Appls & Info Technology, Intro Programming
Strayer: CIS175, CIS111, WRK100, MAT210
Posts: 2,859
Threads: 143
Likes Received: 1,700 in 1,000 posts
Likes Given: 825
Joined: Jun 2017
(03-09-2022, 01:14 PM)rachel83az Wrote: I'm not sure that nursing could be considered a humanities degree. But the point still stands that there are some very important humanities degrees. Very true. I'd argue all degrees have some merit but I think it comes down to the supply of grads with a particular degree entering the workforce vs the demand for people with that degree. We clearly don't need a large percentage of the population getting history degrees, but we don't want history grads to drop to zero either. How do we get the universities and employers to "meet in the middle?" Maybe ensuring humanities degrees include some more courses that teach "practical" skills for employment outside of the major?
WGU BSIT Complete January 2022
(77CU transferred in)(44/44CU )
RA(non WGU)(57cr)
JST/TESU Eval of NAVY Training(85/99cr)
The Institutes, TEEX, NFA(9cr): Ethics, Cyber 101/201/301, Safety
Sophia(60cr): 23 classes
Study.com(31cr): Eng105, Fin102, His108, LibSci101, Math104, Stat101, CS107, CS303, BUS107
CLEP(9cr): Intro Sociology 63 Intro Psych 61 US GOV 71
OD(12cr): Robotics, Cyber, Programming, Microecon
CSM(3cr)
Various IT/Cybersecurity Certifications from: CompTIA, Google, Microsoft, AWS, GIAC, LPI, IBM
CS Fund. MicroBachelor(3cr)
•
Posts: 1,097
Threads: 41
Likes Received: 353 in 237 posts
Likes Given: 0
Joined: Jun 2020
(03-09-2022, 01:14 PM)rachel83az Wrote: I'm not sure that nursing could be considered a humanities degree. But the point still stands that there are some very important humanities degrees. You absolutely correct, but it’s not really considered stem either. The poster suggested eliminating student loans for non stem majors.
Posts: 551
Threads: 16
Likes Received: 484 in 269 posts
Likes Given: 3
Joined: Apr 2020
(03-09-2022, 11:45 AM)bluebooger Wrote: "Humanities degrees and STEM degrees deserve equal respect"
no
in fact, I think student loans should only go to STEM degrees
that should have the effect of actually lowering the cost of non-STEM degrees
and actually weeding out the useless degrees The practical impact of that would be to force many students who have no interest in STEM to pursue STEM degrees. India is actually an excellent example of this sort of thing actually happening. The IIT schools are the best in the country and teach, basically, STEM. Many of the best students go to IIT schools, earn STEM degrees and then go into business or other areas. I actually had 2 classmates in my history PhD program who were from India and had engineering undergraduate degrees. They earned their degrees because that’s what the best students in India did, never mind their lack of interest in the subject. If loans to non-STEM degree earners stopped, there would be many more people, I think, who earned their STEM degree but never “used” it. Perversely, if you didn’t dramatically increase the size of STEM programs, you would almost certainly worsen shortages for STEM workers, drive up STEM salaries, and likely have to bring even more foreign workers with STEM degrees.
There are already shortages of professors in many STEM disciplines and they tend to be much higher paid than in many of the social sciences/humanities. Part of why universities love humanities/social sciences is they can charge the same tuition to someone earning a history degree and someone earning a physics, computer science, or accounting degree, but pay the history faculty say1/3-1/2 what they would pay in other disciplines. More demand for faculty will drive up prices (salaries) for professors even more. It would also pull even more people from working in STEM to put them in classrooms, further driving up costs (salaries) across broad swaths of the economy.
It also occurs to me that for centuries, from antiquity to the industrial revolution, what we now recognize as the humanities were really the most prized disciplines. The precursors to today’s engineers, doctors, architects, businesspeople, and scientists were often not welcome in proper society. No proper gentleman or lady would condescend to studying in these fields. If there were no student aid for the humanities, might we return to that? If STEM degrees become degrees for poor people, why would a wealthy or socially powerful person want one? A history degree might become, by its cost and scarcity, a marker of social standing. Perhaps the history degree would become, as it’s precursor was a few hundred years ago, a way of confirming or even entering the highest rungs of society.
That, or we will just stop teaching it in any meaningful way. Most of the state legislatures seem to be working toward that already, but that’s a post for a different board/different part of the board…
Master of Accountancy (taxation concentration), University of Texas Rio Grande Valley, in progress.
Master of Business Administration (financial planning specialization), University of Texas Rio Grande Valley, in progress.
BA, UMPI. Accounting major; Business Administration major/Management & Leadership concentration. Awarded Dec. 2021.
In-person/B&M: BA (history, archaeology)
In-person/B&M: MA (American history)
Sophia: 15 courses (42hrs)
Posts: 8,313
Threads: 91
Likes Received: 3,457 in 2,479 posts
Likes Given: 4,091
Joined: May 2020
03-09-2022, 04:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-09-2022, 05:01 PM by ss20ts.)
(03-09-2022, 11:45 AM)bluebooger Wrote: "Humanities degrees and STEM degrees deserve equal respect"
no
in fact, I think student loans should only go to STEM degrees
that should have the effect of actually lowering the cost of non-STEM degrees
and actually weeding out the useless degrees
So no student loans for:
culinary and hospitality programs
nursing
psychology programs
social work and human services programs
elementary school teaching
business degrees
banking/finance and insurance degrees
accounting degrees
law degrees
law enforcement
emergency management
automechanics programs
agricultural programs
horticultural programs
carpentry and other building sciences which aren't considered STEM
How exactly would you propose one earns a degree in these programs and others without student loans?
(03-09-2022, 04:30 PM)freeloader Wrote: The practical impact of that would be to force many students who have no interest in STEM to pursue STEM degrees. India is actually an excellent example of this sort of thing actually happening. The IIT schools are the best in the country and teach, basically, STEM. Many of the best students go to IIT schools, earn STEM degrees and then go into business or other areas. I actually had 2 classmates in my history PhD program who were from India and had engineering undergraduate degrees. They earned their degrees because that’s what the best students in India did, never mind their lack of interest in the subject. If loans to non-STEM degree earners stopped, there would be many more people, I think, who earned their STEM degree but never “used” it. Perversely, if you didn’t dramatically increase the size of STEM programs, you would almost certainly worsen shortages for STEM workers, drive up STEM salaries, and likely have to bring even more foreign workers with STEM degrees.
There are already shortages of professors in many STEM disciplines and they tend to be much higher paid than in many of the social sciences/humanities. Part of why universities love humanities/social sciences is they can charge the same tuition to someone earning a history degree and someone earning a physics, computer science, or accounting degree, but pay the history faculty say1/3-1/2 what they would pay in other disciplines. More demand for faculty will drive up prices (salaries) for professors even more. It would also pull even more people from working in STEM to put them in classrooms, further driving up costs (salaries) across broad swaths of the economy.
It also occurs to me that for centuries, from antiquity to the industrial revolution, what we now recognize as the humanities were really the most prized disciplines. The precursors to today’s engineers, doctors, architects, businesspeople, and scientists were often not welcome in proper society. No proper gentleman or lady would condescend to studying in these fields. If there were no student aid for the humanities, might we return to that? If STEM degrees become degrees for poor people, why would a wealthy or socially powerful person want one? A history degree might become, by its cost and scarcity, a marker of social standing. Perhaps the history degree would become, as it’s precursor was a few hundred years ago, a way of confirming or even entering the highest rungs of society.
That, or we will just stop teaching it in any meaningful way. Most of the state legislatures seem to be working toward that already, but that’s a post for a different board/different part of the board…
There are many people who have ZERO interest in STEM programs because they're not good at those subjects. Everyone's brain does not work the same. Creative people tend to be awful at math and science. They can study math until the cows come home and never understand it.
So many people who have no interest in the STEM field especially those who aren't good at those subjects are to do what? Remain uneducated? Rely on the government to take care of them since they can't be educated? Are they to be homeless and starving because they don't understand math and science? That's really humane. STEM programs aren't any better than humanities or any other programs. They all are necessary. Someone needs to know how to repair diesel trucks so your computer parts can be shipped around the globe.
|
